6) 2006 Denver Broncos-
Record: 9-7
Points Scored: 319 (19.9)
Points Against: 305 (19.1)
Highlight: The Broncos got off to a 7-2 start to the season backed by a dominating and suffocating defense. From games two through six, Denver's defense allowed the following points each game: 6,7,3,3, and 7. They also defeated New England and Baltimore (Combined 2006 Record: 25-7), beat defending Super Bowl Champion Pittsburgh on the road, and lost at home to eventual Super Bowl XLI Champ Indy by three. The Broncos had established themselves as AFC West contenders and a real threat to get to the Super Bowl.
Lowlight: Denver's loss to San Francisco in Week 17 knocked the Broncos from playoff contention. The 49ers were 6-9 heading into Denver, and all the Broncos had to do was win and they were in. Denver took a 13-0 first half lead with help from Champ Bailey's 70 yard interception return. The Niners stormed back to completely take control of the game in the second half. Trailing 23-16 late in the fourth quarter, Jay Cutler engineered an Elway-like drive and hit TE Tony Scheffler with a 9 yard touchdown pass to tie the game at 23 and send it to overtime. In overtime, Denver had the ball twice, but they couldn't get the deciding points. San Francisco buried the Bronco playoff hopes with a Joe Nedney 36 yard field goal to win it. Denver was eliminated from playoff contention and archrival Kansas City gained entry to the playoffs with the Bronco defeat. To make matters worse, Darrent Williams was shot and killed late that night after an argument at a Denver nightclub. That day and ensuing evening could be considered the worst moment in recent Broncos history.
What If?: The 2006 Broncos bring about the ultimate "What If?" of the decade. At 7-4, Mike Shanahan decided to bench starting QB Jake Plummer (A fan favorite and unquestionable team leader) and go with rookie first-round pick Jay Cutler. Shanny felt that Cutler gave the team the best chance to improve their offensive performance. Many people, myself included, thought it was a good move because it would shake up a stagnant offense and it gave the Broncos a chance to give Cutler valuable experience because he was the future of the franchise. It was an interesting proposition: Do you sacrifice a possible playoff berth to give a rookie QB valuable playing experience or do you stick with your veteran leader and make the playoffs? Even if your Super Bowl chances are slim, do you still make that move? I must admit at the time I liked the move to Cutler. Years later it was a bad move by Shanahan. If Shanny sticks with Plummer, there is no way Denver loses to Seattle at home in Week 13. Denver's defense dominated the Seahawks all game long, but Cutler threw a pick six, and he struggled all night going 10-21 with 143 yards and two interceptions. Plummer would have won that game for Denver. If Denver wins just that game, then they will make the playoffs at 10-6. They would have opened up on the road at New England. Although they probably would have lost to the Pats, they did beat them earlier in the 17-7 in Foxboro. Plus, in the NFL playoffs it is a one game tournament. You never know what could have happened. The bottom line is that you never trade a playoff berth for developing the future of your team. Playoff berths are very hard and rare to come by, and Shanahan made a mistake by benching Plummer and going with Cutler.
5) 2002 Denver Broncos-
Record: 9-7
Points Scored: 392 (24.5)
Points Against: 344 (21.5)
Highlight: A 6-2 start and first place in the AFC West at the midway point of the season. The first half included big wins over both Super Bowl participants from the year before (23-16 over St.Louis and 24-16 over New England). Also, Denver won a rare game at Arrowhead over the Chiefs 37-34 in overtime. Denver rallied from 34-20 hole in the fourth quarter and won it in OT on Jason Elam field goal. It was and still is one of the most thrilling Bronco victories in the entire decade.
Lowlight: The Broncos playoff hopes ended in the Black Hole with a tough loss to the Raiders 28-16. It was a game that Brian Griese called the biggest of his career, but it turned out to be his last ever as a Bronco. At 8-6, if Denver won their final two games they would win the AFC West. All the Raiders had to do was beat Denver in Week 16, and they would clinch the AFC West. The Broncos fell behind 21-0 early in the second quarter, and Griese was awful. He was 7-15 with two interceptions before being knocked out of the game by Bill Romanowski (Talk about revenge). Steve Beuerlein entered the game and actually rallied the Broncos. Beuerlein brought Denver back and Denver only trailed 21-18 midway through the fourth quarter. Unfortunately, the Raiders were able to hold them off and put the game away on Zack Crockett 1 yard touchdown run late in the fourth. The Raiders clinched the AFC West, and Denver was dealt a huge blow to their playoff hopes. The Broncos would need a lot of help in Week 17, and they didn't get it (Cleveland won), and the Broncos missed the playoffs for the second consecutive season.
What If? No offense to the Colts or Browns that year, but the 2002 Denver Broncos were a playoff team that year. The Broncos lost so many brutal games that they deserve their own DVD titled, "Worse Regular Season Losses in One Season." Exhibit A: A stunning 24-22 loss at home to Miami in Week 6. The Broncos drove late and Jason Elam nailed a 55 yard field goal to give the Broncos a 22-21 lead. John Mobley drops a surefire interception on the ensuing drive, and Olindo Mare nails a 53 yarder at the buzzer to win it for the Fish. The loss drops Denver to 4-2. Exhibit B: A 23-20 overtime loss at home to Indy on Sunday Night Football. In a game played in a blizzard, Denver unveils their orange alternate jerseys for the first time. Up 20-17 in the fourth quarter, all Denver needs is a first down to ice the game. On 3rd and 3, Shanny calls for a pass, and Steve Buerlein's attempt to Ed McCaffrey is incomplete. With the ball and a chance, Peyton Manning drives the Colts enough to give Mike Vanderjagt a chance at a 54 yard field goal in the wind and snow. Of course, Vanderjagt drills it and sends the game to OT. In overtime, Vanderjagt nails a 51 yarder to beat the Broncos and drop them to 7-4. Exhibit C: A Week 13 loss at San Diego in overtime 30-27. The Broncos jump out to a 10-0 lead, but soon fall behind 21-1o in the second quarter. The Broncos tie the game at 24 in the third quarter, and Jason Elam hits a 24 yarder to tie the game at 27 late in the game. In overtime, Denver blocks a field goal by San Diego, but they can't get a first down, so they punt the ball back to the Chargers. San Diego drives down the field, with help from Drew Brees, and wins in it on a Steve Christie 27 yard field goal. The loss drops Denver to 7-5. Exhibit D: A 19-13 loss at the hands of the New York Jets in the Meadowlands. The loss drops Denver to 7-6. The Broncos are clinging to a 13-9 lead as they head into the fourth quarter. The Jets get 10 points to take a 19-13 lead. The Broncos get the ball back late, and Brian Griese begins the drive the Broncos down the field into Jet territory. The drive is highlighted by a huge Griese to Shannon Sharpe pass. Griese again hits Sharpe to put the Broncos inside the Jet 15, but a mysterious holding call wipes out the play. A few plays later, Griese terribly overthrows Rod Smith at the Jets 1o yard line and Jet safety Jon McGraw picks him off to seal the game.
Those four losses were absolutely brutal. If the Broncos win one of those games they are in the playoffs in '02. If Denver beats Indy in Week 12, then the Broncos are 10-6 and the 5th seed going to New York to play the Jets- a very winnable game. Even if Denver loses to Indy, but won any of the other three games, they are the 6 seed and headed to Pittsburgh to play Tommy Maddox and the Steelers-once again a very winnable game. Don't forget that Bronco team was paced by a rookie running back named Clinton Portis. The Broncos running attack with Portis would have given them a really good chance in any playoff game on the road that year. It is a shame that the 2002 Denver Broncos didn't make the playoffs. Just a shame.